Redshaw Insurance – Protecting your most important assets

At Redshaw Insurance Agency, we believe insurance should feel personal—not just a policy, but a relationship built on trust, clarity, and care. We’re here to serve you, plain and simple. Whether you’re protecting your home, your business, your car, or your livelihood, our team works to find coverage that fits your life—and your budget.

We’re proud to offer competitive rates, but what truly sets us apart is the way we show up for our clients. When you call, we answer. When you have questions, we explain. And when life takes an unexpected turn, we’re here to help you through it.

Great coverage matters—but great service is what keeps our clients coming back. Let’s find the protection that’s right for you.

"They are the best and always take care of us. We’ve never had a better insurance company." - Lisa
"We've had Redshaw for our insurance needs ever since moving to Rushville, 20+ years ago. Highly recommend! Great service! He's always looking for better rates, even calling me when he finds a better deal to save me money. Joe is very personable and has a great team working beside him." - Amy
"Redshaw Insurance is the best around hands down going on five years with them and nothing but superb service and help when needed." - Nick
"Highly recommend Redshaw insurance. Great service. Been with them for years." - Cindy

Our Services

Auto Insurance

Whether it’s your daily driver or your weekend truck, your vehicle deserves solid coverage. We’ll help you find a plan that keeps you protected without overcomplicating things.

Home Insurance

Your home is more than just a place, it's where life happens. We provide customized coverage to protect what matters most, from the foundation to the furniture.

Farm Insurance

Your farm is your livelihood, let’s keep it covered. We offer tailored protection for your home, equipment, livestock, and crops so you can keep things growing strong.

Business Insurance

Running a business is tough. Insurance shouldn’t be. We’ll help protect what you’ve worked hard to build, plain and simple.

Life Insurance

Make sure your loved ones are taken care of, no matter what life throws your way. We’ll help you find coverage that makes sense for you and your family.

Medicare Supplement Insurance

You deserve coverage you can feel confident in. We’re here to help you protect what matters most with the right supplement plan.